%    debate_Rule_JP.txt    Rbrs 1.0
%    Copyright (C) 1988, Katsumi Nitta    (nitta@dis.titech.ac.jp)
%                        Taketomo Katoh   (tkatoh@ntt.dis.titech.ac.jp)

                  ǥѥ롼١

ƥɾѤΥǥǡ(rdebate_Dic, debate_Rule)Ȥ
ơ칩رظǽƥʳ칶ǹԤ줿 E-mail
ǥ١(1987) A7  A8 ɤλΥǡܥƥΥ롼
ѤǤϤΥǡƤ롥


롼

(r1) ԤξǯˡǤ꤬ͭꡤ̤ʤǤ
ȽǤ򲼤Ȥ뤳Ȥ顤ǯˡŬǯ 12 Ͱʲ˰
٤Ǥ롥

(r2) ԤξǯˡϾǯȺλǧڻ뤷Ƥ뤳ȡζ
Ⱥ᤬äƤ뤳ȡƾǯȺμҲؤΰƶ礭Ȥ
꤬ͭ롥

(r3)ǯκΨ 42.5 % ȹ⤯ǯˡι̤ʤ

(r4) ȽǤ򲼤ȤǤ롥

(r5) ǯȺλǧڻ뤷Ƥ롥

(r6) ǯϺΰռ㤤ᡤǯȺ᤬ҲͿƶ礭

(r7) ǯϺΰռ㤤

(r8) ǯκΨ 42.5 % Ǥ롥

(r9) ǯκΨ 42.5 % Ǥ뤬ȺκȤʤṹ
̤ʤǤϤʤ

(r10)  5 ǯλͻäƤʤζȺ
äƤʤ

(r11) ǯˡ 12 ͤ˰ȷˡȿȤʤ뤿ᡤǯˡŬ
Ѥ 12 Ͱʲˤ٤ǤϤʤ

(r12) ǯˡ 12 ͤ˰뤳ȤϫƯˡȿȤʤ뤿ᡤǯˡŬ
Ѥ 12 Ͱʲˤ٤ǤϤʤ

(r13) ǯζȺκȤ 2.5 % Ǥ뤿ᡤΨϾʤ

(r14) ǯλͤϤ 5 ǯѲʤ

(r15) ǯˡ 12 ͤ˰ȷˡȿȤʤ롥

(r16) ǯˡ 12 ͤ˰뤳ȤϫƯˡȿȤʤ롥

(r17) ζȺϺǯ 20.5 % äƤΤǡȺ
äƤ롥

(r18) ζȺϺǯ 20.5 % äƤ롥

(r19) ǯζȺΨ 2.5 % Ͼʤʤ

(r20)  λͤ 5 ǯѲʤȤ 16 ̤Υǡ
ʤᡤˤʤʤ

(r21) ˡˤϽȷ෺ʤᡤȿˤϤʤʤ

(r22) ˡΧϫƯˡȿˤϤʤʤ

(r23) ΨϹ⤤.

(r24) ΨϹ⤤ȤϤʤ.

(r25) 16 ̤Υǡʤ

(r26) ˡˤϽȷʤ

(r27) ȽθˤȽǤ򲼤зˡǻ෺Ϥʤʤ롥

(r28) ˡΧ롥

(r29) ෺ϺȽȽǤ򲼤

(r30) ȽϾθˤ롥

(r31) ෺ϺȽȽǤ򲼤ᡤˡ˻෺ʤǤϤʤ

(r32) ǯκȽˤʤȻҶθ򿯳ΤǾǯˡŬ
 12 Ͱʲˤ٤ǤϤʤ

(r33) ˡϺȽϸǤ롥

(r34) ǯθ򿯳롥

(r35) ϻ෺εػߤƤΤǤϤʤ෺μ¹ԤػߤƤơ
ϹˡΧ˰¸뤿ᡤˡϷˡȿˤϤʤʤ

(r36) ϻ෺εػߤƤʤ

(r37) ϻ෺μ¹ԤػߤƤ롥

(r38) Ϲˡ˰¸Ƥ롥

(r39) Ҥä䶲϶ȺǤϤʤ

(r40) ȶ϶̤Ǥʤ

(r41) Ҥäⶲ⶧ȺǤ롥

(r42) ȺηڽŤˤ餺Ⱥ򤷤ȤŻ뤹٤.

(r43) ȺŻ뤹٤.

(r44) 򸷤ͤ٤.

(r45) 򸷤ͤ٤Ǥʤ.

(r46) ҴŪʥǡΤߤͤ٤.

(r47) ǡҴŪˤΤߤȤ館٤Ǥʤ.

(r48) Ǥ¤нŻ뤹٤.


ͥ롼

(p1) ΨˤĤƤθʬ줿顢⤤ȤŻ뤹٤.

(p2) ΨˤĤƤθʬ줿顢㤤ȤŻ뤹٤.

(p3) Ϳ򸫤ȶȺäƤʤ.

(p4) ǯߤȶȺäƤ.

(p5) Ⱥ򤷤ȼΤŻ뤹ʤ顢Ҥä⶧Ⱥ˴ޤƹͤ
٤.

(p6) ȺΤߤŻ뤹ʤ顢Ҥä򶧰Ⱥ˴ޤƹͤ
ϹԤ.

(p7) 򸷤ͤʤ(P1)(p2)ͥ褹٤.

(p8) ׾ҴŪ˸븫(p4)ȼŪ˸븫(p3)ΩȤϡ
ҴŪ˸٤.

(p9) Ĥβ(r15, r35)ΩƤƤ⡢⤷(r35)꿮Τ
󤬤СβȤ٤.

                                     ʾ


